Can you suggest ways to enrich this image to extend its ethnographic import?

Annotations

Enter a comma separated list of user names.
Allana L Ross's picture
March 11, 2020
In response to:

I really can't. The image tells a rich story: I can see the fish, the harvest that will become commodity, freshly drawn from a landscape whose toxicity is implied by the industrial background. It's clear what is going on and the composition itself is pleasing.

Louise Elstow's picture
March 11, 2020

I wonder if as a way of illustrating the point that you make - whether you could find a ceremony of a military chaplain?  As that would bring together the religious aspect, the intertis and the military.  

Diana Pardo Pedraza's picture
March 10, 2020
In response to:

It is a powerful first image for the photo essay, and I like the image as it is, yet the caption needs to do more work. 

Shilpa Dahake's picture
March 9, 2020
In response to:

If possible the ethnographer can add locations of the landmines and areas destructed by legacies of war, illegal mining and illicit crop production. This will enrich the image by showing overlaps of multiple narratives of toxicities.

Fu Yu Chang's picture
March 7, 2020

In the visual there is an explanation about the words in red and the words in green.  What do the words in yellow represent? It would be interesting if there were some kind of representation contrasting what residents (or even activists) think about the text.

Fu Yu Chang's picture
March 7, 2020
In response to:

The caption reminds us of ever present toxics in our daily lives. I would love to hear more about the deeper connection of this multiple toxicities the author hints at. Does Velu talk about these other sites of contamination? Do people differentiate between one form of toxicity and another? I love the description about the nets as a direct point of contact / point of entry to toxicity, could the author tell us more about these interconnections?

Shilpa Dahake's picture
March 7, 2020

According to me, the image is aptly suggestive of the narrative associated with it.

Monique Azzara's picture
March 7, 2020
In response to:

It would be beneficial if there was a way to enhance the image since it is slightly pixilated and difficult to read. Maybe also consider showing the step with the original statement, which might be a way to actually fully articulated everything your description says through the image itself.

Kaitlyn Rabach's picture
March 6, 2020
In response to:

I think some of the metaphor of having to really search the photo for the settlers actually is part of the ethnographic import of the image, but another tactic could be to actually blur the home, the picket fence, and everything in the photo except the settlers, actualling landing the focus on the people themselves. This might represent what you’re trying to do with the project as a whole. So it would be a sort of reversal of what is being portrayed in the photo now.

Shilpa Dahake's picture
March 6, 2020

The image is an interesting way representing the narrative the ethnographer wants to convey.

Pages